1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Glen Nevis (2 pictures)

Discussion in 'Appraisal Gallery' started by Helander, Oct 12, 2014.

  1. Helander

    Helander Well-Known Member

    I'd appreciate your thoughts on these two pictures. They are the same frame but 2 different treatments.

    [​IMG]


    [​IMG]


    Thank you for looking.
     
  2. BikerMike

    BikerMike Well-Known Member

    Oooh, they are absolutely lovely, both of them.

    I think the B&W wins as it gives a more dramatic atmosphere to it without losing anything essential - and contains just a fraction more detail over to the right, where there's a faint line of trees in the mist with the mountain behind.

    I could live with a large blow-up of that on my wall. :)

    Very nicely captured.

    Regards, Mike
     
  3. lfc1892

    lfc1892 Well-Known Member

    Like the mono, love the colour. Great atmosphere.
     
  4. dream_police

    dream_police Well-Known Member

    I'm torn between the two. Think the colour just takes it. Very nice.
     
  5. gray1720

    gray1720 Well-Known Member

    ...whereas just to be awkward I think the ghostly mono takes it.

    Adrian
     
  6. Ffolrord

    Ffolrord Well-Known Member

    Mono for me as both Sun and foreground are less dominant. Very nice shot.
     
  7. 0lybacker

    0lybacker In the Stop Bath

    Good work. Like the colour best. Unusually for me, I'd also suggest a slight trim off the right hand side to make edge to tree equal on both sides.
     
  8. dachs

    dachs Well-Known Member

    I'd chew your arm off for either shot, but leaning to the mono. Only by a fraction though.
     
  9. AdrianSadlier

    AdrianSadlier Well-Known Member

    Colour for me. Love the hint of blue in the sky and what the day may hold. Both are great.
     
  10. reading17

    reading17 Member

    Like the black and white one, a great photo.
     
  11. nickyr

    nickyr Well-Known Member

    love both of them - but if I had to choose just one to print and hang it would be the colour version
     
  12. AlexMonro

    AlexMonro Old Grand Part Deux

    Both lovely, but for me, the treatment of the light around the sun in the mono gives it the edge.
     
  13. henniehendrik

    henniehendrik Well-Known Member

    both work ,.but going by my immediate reaction its the color all the way...printed huge.love the tones.
     

Share This Page