https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p070bfh0 but not in detail. I like Edinburgh except for one set of things. Tourists. There are too many bloody tourists. The tax is not enough. I would suggest a tax depending upon season and events. Of course when I visit Edinburgh I am a tourist but I would willingly pay the tax if it reduced the numbers. I would charge day visitors more than those spending money for overnight accomadation.