Amateur Photographer Magazine

Skip to Content
Digital Photography Forum - A shared resource

Community >> From the Top

 |  Print Thread
Footloose
Carpal \'Tunnel


Reged: 11/08/2005
Posts: 3188
Loc: Berkshire based.
Re: Poll - full frame still important?
      06/07/2008 02:12

I've never used a camera with a full-frame sensor, so I can't personally quantify it's benefits over the APS-C sensor. However I suspect that although the various reviews cite that it offers advantages over the APS-C format, we may well find that to extract the optimum quality from this, (specifically in relation to wide and ultra-wide lenses) a range of reformulated (Telecentric?) optics using a new larger diameter bayonet mount will be eventually needed.

I also have the sneaking feeling the main reason a lot of photographers in the past wanted a 35mm format sensor, was so they can use their existing lenses, because they begrudge shelling out their hard-earned cash on new ones!

The APS-C sensor, evades this thorny issue of a new lens mount, and since the sensor only uses about 3/4 of the Angle of View (AoV) used by the 35mm film format, unwanted artefacts like fringing etc at the edges of the optics FoV do not show up. What would seem to back up this guess of mine, is the fact that it's only been recently that ultra-wide optics have begun to appear for the APS-C format, whilst Olympus have been selling their fast, ultra-wide 7-14mm zoom, (= a 14-28mm on the 35mm format) since 2005.

--------------------
Trainee reprobate with a pronounced limp (spelt L .. I .. M .. P.)

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Poll - full frame still important? Damien DemolderModerator 06/07/2008 00:03
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? TimF   11/07/2008 10:16
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Hotblack   08/07/2008 11:41
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? deddard   08/07/2008 08:27
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Iloca   08/07/2008 11:43
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? alanS   08/07/2008 12:23
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Iloca   08/07/2008 12:45
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   08/07/2008 13:19
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Iloca   08/07/2008 13:35
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   08/07/2008 14:02
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Iloca   08/07/2008 14:29
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? BenchistaModerator   08/07/2008 14:38
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Iloca   08/07/2008 14:53
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? alanS   08/07/2008 15:14
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Footloose   08/07/2008 16:08
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Iloca   08/07/2008 15:22
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? BenchistaModerator   08/07/2008 11:50
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Footloose   08/07/2008 10:26
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   08/07/2008 12:29
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? El Sid   07/07/2008 12:53
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? noangel   06/07/2008 21:30
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? BenchistaModerator   06/07/2008 15:51
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? NorthernNikon   07/07/2008 10:18
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? BenchistaModerator   07/07/2008 10:34
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? NorthernNikon   07/07/2008 10:57
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   07/07/2008 11:49
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   07/07/2008 12:02
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? NorthernNikon   07/07/2008 12:04
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   07/07/2008 13:43
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? barney britton   07/07/2008 15:46
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Nod   07/07/2008 11:37
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? NorthernNikon   07/07/2008 11:59
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Nod   07/07/2008 12:08
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? NorthernNikon   07/07/2008 12:17
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? LargeFormat   07/07/2008 14:57
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Nod   07/07/2008 12:20
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? NorthernNikon   07/07/2008 13:00
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   07/07/2008 11:37
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   07/07/2008 12:03
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   07/07/2008 12:22
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? LargeFormat   07/07/2008 11:23
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? BenchistaModerator   07/07/2008 12:20
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? LargeFormat   06/07/2008 14:49
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Footloose   06/07/2008 16:05
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? barney britton   07/07/2008 15:38
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   07/07/2008 16:42
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? barney britton   07/07/2008 16:48
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? zuiko   07/07/2008 18:59
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   07/07/2008 19:33
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? zuiko   07/07/2008 20:14
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Nod   08/07/2008 11:41
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? zuiko   08/07/2008 18:34
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   07/07/2008 20:52
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   07/07/2008 17:05
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Garry McNamara   07/07/2008 16:54
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? NorthernNikon   07/07/2008 17:14
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Nod   07/07/2008 18:25
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Nod   07/07/2008 16:55
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Malcolm_Stewart   06/07/2008 10:55
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Terrywoodenpic   06/07/2008 11:32
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   06/07/2008 12:51
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? LargeFormat   06/07/2008 16:35
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Zou   06/07/2008 12:08
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Garry McNamara   06/07/2008 08:32
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? gollum   06/07/2008 22:56
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? TarquinBiscuit   07/07/2008 08:49
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? parisian   07/07/2008 09:29
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? TarquinBiscuit   07/07/2008 09:47
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? sjaszczak   06/07/2008 08:49
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   06/07/2008 09:02
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Damien DemolderModerator   06/07/2008 17:57
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   06/07/2008 20:12
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Scphoto   06/07/2008 18:41
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? BenchistaModerator   06/07/2008 18:51
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? daft_bikerModerator   06/07/2008 20:14
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Garry McNamara   06/07/2008 20:52
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Footloose   06/07/2008 10:32
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? BenchistaModerator   06/07/2008 01:10
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Footloose   06/07/2008 02:12
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? hech54   06/07/2008 07:44
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Dave_Cox   06/07/2008 07:36
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? beejaybee   06/07/2008 00:52
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? FujiSigmaNolta   06/07/2008 00:56
. * * Re: Poll - full frame still important? Learning   06/07/2008 00:39

Extra information
0 registered and 2 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  AndrewC, Fen, Damien Demolder, Siuya, GCW, Benchista, huwevans, TheFatControlleR, mark_jacobs, daft_biker, Myk.R 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 6365

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement Main website

Generated in 0.035 seconds in which 0.011 seconds were spent on a total of 12 queries. Zlib compression disabled.