Amateur Photographer Magazine

Skip to Content
Digital Photography Forum - A shared resource

Technical Discussions: Digital >> Scanning & Printing

 |  Print Thread
BrianT
Old Hand


Reged: 16/05/2001
Posts: 5987
Loc: Leeds
Re: In the good old days
      18/05/2008 09:56

I do find it very difficult to reply to somebody without using a name so.


SqueamishOssifrage


Thanks for the trouble you have taken with your reply. So it woud seem that in terms of resolution you are saying that an Epson R1800 is more capable than a D2xs. Now we would be led to believe that the D3 is on another planet to the D2xs so maybe the gap has narrowed, maybe the camera now is better, I just wonder. And would it be fair to expect a Sigma 30mm F1.4 a rather eosoteric lens to have the equal or higher resolution to your Zeiss 50mm F1.4.? It could be that you were testing lenses rather than cameras/printers.

The only thing is I have just printed a D3 file from the Nikon site to A3 and WOW to all intents and purpose this ain't a substitute for 35MM it's M/F at it's best.

If only the D3 wasn't such a clumsy lump.......Oh dear. But I am sure the D300 ain't that far behind although at present I can't find a decent sample to download....American football piccies BAH.

Note to AP.

Would a head to head article, Nikon F6 with 105mm macro or something similar against D3 with ditto, both printed on an Epson ( or whatever is considered best) printer to A3 ? And for the purpose of the test both film and digital set at 200-400 ISO. Because over that I'm sure the film fans would shout foul.

To my mind that would show the average guy what he would get from FF and £2000 over the D300 if any. Obviously only in terms of image quality


You don't know if they did I might even buy a copy.

Edited by BrianT (18/05/2008 10:02)

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* In the good old day's BrianT 16/05/2008 09:42
. * * Re: In the good old days Malcolm_Stewart   16/05/2008 13:00
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   16/05/2008 16:21
. * * Re: In the good old days Malcolm_Stewart   16/05/2008 16:41
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   16/05/2008 16:54
. * * Re: In the good old days Roger_Provins   16/05/2008 17:26
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   16/05/2008 17:36
. * * Re: In the good old days john_g   16/05/2008 18:48
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   16/05/2008 19:04
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   17/05/2008 07:07
. * * Re: In the good old days john_g   17/05/2008 19:40
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   17/05/2008 20:00
. * * Re: In the good old days SqueamishOssifrage   18/05/2008 09:05
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   18/05/2008 09:56
. * * Re: In the good old days NorthernNikon   18/05/2008 23:51
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   19/05/2008 07:26
. * * Re: In the good old days NorthernNikon   19/05/2008 09:04
. * * Re: In the good old days FenModerator   19/05/2008 09:09
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   19/05/2008 09:47
. * * Re: In the good old days FenModerator   19/05/2008 09:59
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   19/05/2008 10:12
. * * Re: In the good old days NorthernNikon   19/05/2008 10:04
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   19/05/2008 10:20
. * * Re: In the good old days NorthernNikon   19/05/2008 11:21
. * * Re: In the good old days BrianT   19/05/2008 14:31
. * * Re: In the good old days NorthernNikon   19/05/2008 15:45
. * * Re: In the good old days Monobod   23/05/2008 09:40
. * * Re: In the good old days john_g   23/05/2008 19:45
. * * Re: In the good old days Monobod   13/06/2008 00:22
. * * Re: In the good old days digitravel   24/05/2008 00:50
. * * Re: In the good old days Seven..   12/06/2008 23:03
. * * Re: In the good old days Malcolm_Stewart   23/05/2008 20:39
. * * Re: In the good old days beejaybee   23/05/2008 21:10

Extra information
0 registered and 0 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Damien Demolder, Fen, Siuya, GCW, Benchista, huwevans, Nigel Atherton, TheFatControlleR, AndrewC, mark_jacobs, daft_biker, Myk.R 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 3425

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement Main website

Generated in 0.026 seconds in which 0.009 seconds were spent on a total of 12 queries. Zlib compression disabled.