Amateur Photographer Magazine

Skip to Content
Digital Photography Forum - A shared resource

Community >> From the Top

 |  Print Thread
Tacitus
History


Reged: 17/01/2006
Posts: 871
Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll
      01/03/2008 20:44

Ok, Damien, I’ll play … Only 'cos there’s nothing on the TV

Answer to question:

Full-frame digital M could/should appear first: if it's a poor camera it'll destroy Leica almost overnight. If it's a good one almost every M-user will want one and most would probably buy one. Size is constrained only by the lens design (backfocus), and isnt' a critical matter.

A digital-R should be the 'new R3' - that is a Canon-Leica collaboration. But there are some really big issues to address with an AF-capable (presumably) digital-R compared to a 'simpler' manual focussing digital M.

However, both are high risk strategies in so many ways.

I want a full-frame digital M (FFDM) that renders satisfactory super-wide images with lenses from 28mm to 12mm. If I can get satisfactory quality & resolution for exhibition work I really won't care too much about the size of the sensor. Cumulative cost is a big issue, so I will want to use lenses from Leica, Voigtlander and Zeiss - without undue technical or performance compromises, etc. But I also want to use all my old M & LTM Leica, Canon, Konica, Nikon, and Voigtlander lenses without cropping, so full-frame inevitably becomes the holy grail.

This is what users on various forums are shouting for, but should Leica take any notice? After all, most of 'us' are more committed to the secondhand lens market than the new lens market - clearly not satisfactory for Leica Camera AG - enter the Summarits.

I also want more functionality in an M9(etc) than the M8 offers, like evaluative metering & AF confirmation. Technically a full-frame digital-M sounds like a bit of a nightmare regarding integration of M lenses, especially wides. It would clearly be expensive to develop, but could have a potentially large, well-established niche market of M-users willing to upgrade to a digital body. Return on investment would probably be fair, since the product life-span could be quite long, unless Zeiss or Voigtlander queer the pitch with a full-frame digital-ZM or VM first ... and providing there are no more technical glitches.

A digital-R is a different ball-game: put bluntly what's the point? Is it just pandering to the vociferous minority, or is there really a viable market for yet another expensive pro-spec DSLR? I don't think so.

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Damien DemolderModerator 01/03/2008 17:23
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Tacitus   02/03/2008 17:26
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll topoxforddoc   02/03/2008 17:46
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll chris000   02/03/2008 16:10
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll hhmr   02/03/2008 18:06
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll hhmr   02/03/2008 15:25
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll beejaybee   02/03/2008 16:03
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll hhmr   02/03/2008 17:48
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Clodhopper   02/03/2008 10:56
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll beejaybee   02/03/2008 11:27
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Dave_Cox   02/03/2008 13:02
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll AGW   03/03/2008 08:17
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll NorthernNikon   03/03/2008 08:44
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll BenchistaModerator   03/03/2008 09:19
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll nspur   03/03/2008 15:47
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Zou   03/03/2008 09:22
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll photo_paul   03/03/2008 15:21
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll BenchistaModerator   03/03/2008 15:49
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Scphoto   07/03/2008 01:29
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Tacitus   07/03/2008 17:50
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Scphoto   07/03/2008 23:00
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll AGW   07/03/2008 21:20
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll El Sid   03/03/2008 17:46
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll AntSmith   04/03/2008 21:08
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll El Sid   05/03/2008 12:30
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll hhmr   06/03/2008 12:52
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll El Sid   06/03/2008 13:03
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll BrianT   15/05/2008 18:44
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll mike_j   15/05/2008 18:59
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll BrianT   15/05/2008 19:13
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll ermintrude   16/05/2008 10:28
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll mike_j   16/05/2008 19:36
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll BrianT   16/05/2008 19:23
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll hhmr   06/03/2008 15:52
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll El Sid   06/03/2008 17:13
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll huwevansModerator   06/03/2008 18:17
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll hhmr   04/03/2008 17:20
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll topoxforddoc   04/03/2008 20:45
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll beejaybee   03/03/2008 09:08
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Tacitus   01/03/2008 20:44
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll beejaybee   01/03/2008 23:11
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll SqueamishOssifrage   02/03/2008 06:55
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll Footloose   02/03/2008 10:26
. * * Re: Which Leica Full Frame First?? Poll BenchistaModerator   01/03/2008 17:24

Extra information
1 registered and 0 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  AndrewC, Fen, Damien Demolder, Siuya, GCW, Benchista, huwevans, TheFatControlleR, mark_jacobs, daft_biker, Myk.R 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 4509

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement Main website

Generated in 0.026 seconds in which 0.008 seconds were spent on a total of 12 queries. Zlib compression disabled.