DaveG40
enthusiast
Reged: 21/07/2007
Posts: 252
|
|
Hi All
Can't remember if I've already asked this one, as I've asked so many questions about superzooms etc, so apologies if I have repeated myself:
Having researched and tinkered with various lenses over the last year I'm less stressed when trying to decide on a lens, as I don't know about anyone else but trying to decide on a lens and then looking at the price can be a bit disconcerting, anyway as well as my kit lens & 50mm Prime I have 2 cracking lenses that are used the most: A sigma 28-200 f/3.5-f/5.6 (which is on 90% of the time) and the bargain lens of all time, the Tamron 55-200 (it only cost me £70 brand new), which is put on for fast action shooting, I'd really like to bring my football action shots on and to do that I'm really going to need a faster lens, does anyone have any suggestions for a lens that can improve on my Tamron's & at less than £300 ?. The beercan, minolta 100-300 and a few others are being considered and I'd really like to know which one would be the better option.
|
Roger_Provins
Made-it Man
Reged: 22/10/2005
Posts: 3059
Loc: Gloucester, UK
|
|
Hi Dave,
Problem is that for many sports one really need a longish fast (f2.8) zoom = expensive! So to manage on a tight budget means compromise. All things considered I'd say get a "beercan", if 210mm is long enough for you, it's the fastest (f4) at that length that'll you'll get for the money.
--------------------
Rog
|
RonM
Reged: 26/04/2001
Posts: 3722
Loc: Scotland
|
|
Dave, I'd agree with Roger, at that sort of money, £300ish, the sort of fast f/2.8 or f/4 Telephotos or Telezooms are probably out of your price range. I've got a 'beercan' 70 - 210 f/4 and it is a great lens, however I don't think it would be my first choice for footie, I'd be more likely to use my 300 f/4 (£600+ S/H)
One lens you did mention which is highly rated is Minoltas 100 - 300 APO as is the 100 - 400 APO, however, they are rare as to availability on the S/H & e-bay markets for just that reason.
It looks like the 'beercan' is going to be your best option, unless you see an older S/H Tamron/Tokina 70 - 200 f/2.8 'A' mount lens going for around the limit of your price range.
Best of luck in your search.
Unless Rog would be willing to loan you his 70 - 300 SSM G lens 
--------------------
Ron NRIPN
Everyone has a photographic memory, some don't have Film or Digital Memory.
Life is a Learning Opportunity 
|
DaveG40
enthusiast
Reged: 21/07/2007
Posts: 252
|
|
Thanks for the response guys, I'll keep an eye on ebay & ffordes.
|
Dorset_Mike
Gadget Man
Reged: 11/05/2006
Posts: 1839
Loc: Poole, Dorset.
|
|
How much do you rely on auto focus? Could you cope with focussing manually given a focus confirm light in the view finder?
If so it may be worth considering a fast M42 fit prime with a chipped adapter, they did manage with them before AF, you should be able to find 300/2.8 or 300/4 there were also a few longer like 400/4 and 500/5.6, various makes, Japanese, German and Russian, the latter often being Zeiss copies. At least with primes you only have to focus, manual focus zooms would maybe slow you down a bit though for action shots!
--------------------
Cheers, MIKE 
 
|
DaveG40
enthusiast
Reged: 21/07/2007
Posts: 252
|
|
I had'nt really given MF much thought, I'll try it out tomorrow and will see if that opens up new avenues, I had thought about adding a x2 telecon to my f/1.7 prime, with the crop factor I'd probably be looking at about 170mm, the question is would the 2 be compatible & would it really matter if I get cosy with MF ?. Any idea what the f-stop would be on a 50mm + x2 convertor combo ?.
|
RonM
Reged: 26/04/2001
Posts: 3722
Loc: Scotland
|
|
Quote:
Any idea what the f-stop would be on a 50mm + x2 convertor combo ?.
Dave a 2 times converter will lose you two stops so the f/1.7 will be something around f/4.5 - 5.6, Oh and with the crop factor of a Sony the 50mm plus 2x will give the 35mm equivalent of a 150mm.
The 70 - 210 f/4 'beercan' will give better results even at wide open throughout the zoom range than your 50mm + 2x, also with the crop factor the beercan will give you an equivalent 105 - 315mm f/4 lens. Check out the image I posted Here
EXIF :- ISO 100, 1/500th, f/5.6, focal length 150mm (225 equivalent) on my Minolta Dynax 7D taken from approx 30+ metres away
--------------------
Ron NRIPN
Everyone has a photographic memory, some don't have Film or Digital Memory.
Life is a Learning Opportunity
|
Previous
Index
Next
Threaded
Edit
Reply
Quote
