GCW
(Überlord)
04/06/2007 14:48
Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Dear Forum Members

Here are the results of the Forum’s May photographic competition.

This month the theme was “Colour” and on reflection I think this is a much harder round than I thought it would be. Why? Well, when you have to interpret the word ‘colour’, I think there is a propensity to try and capture a subject that is colourful or one that has striking colours. Of course this makes perfect sense, but I wonder if sometimes in keeping one’s mind so focussed on colour we have forsaken subject, shape and reason. In essence, the picture must always work as an artistic composition in its on right, regardless of the subject. Having said that, there are some truly nice pictures entered this month and of course, I have to stress that the judging of this competition is all about my taste and views — as we all know photography is very subjective. Lastly, it is great to see so many entries and a big well done to everyone who came to play.

This time I have chosen four Highly Commended’s and one outright Winner. They are as follows:

Highly Commended: AGW — Blue Star

competition winner

This looks more like a piece of graphic art rather than a conventional picture and I salute the observation of AGW in isolating the subject from its environment and knowing what it would look like when cropped. I particularly like the angle from which the image is taken — the shadow on the underside of the star gives a three-dimensional effect. The only fly in the ointment is the spike rising from the apex of the star — but I have chosen to ignore it!

Highly Commended: Datawise — Colour Yellow

competition winner

A beautiful, simple, clean and striking flower image. Very powerful. There were a lot of flower shots and many of them were really great, but this one just kicked bottom in my view. The fact that it faces the viewer full-on, is almost intimidating — a challenge.

Highly Commended: Scphoto — Rock Rose

competition winner

This is an intriguing image. The uneven backlighting adds to the drama and again this image has a three-dimensional aspect. The petals look like paper and I think the stamen has been well-placed to the upper left of centre.

Highly Commended: Jchrisc — Eschscholtzia California

competition winner

This feels peaceful and the composition grows nicely from the where the eye falls on the bottom right to the to top left. I love the fact there are only two colours — orange and green. It feels very peaceful.

Winner: Samsam — A Colourful View

competition winner

Regular AP Forum competition entrants will know that often I will award joint winners, but this month Samsam’s picture is just so good that it just stood out from everything else. I would be interested to know how this image was captured and how much of it is a result of manipulation — but does that matter? I think its all about the end result. I love the viewpoint — very much like the opening credits of a James Bond film with the sweets replacing 007 and positioned just to left of frame. I also think the positioning of the sweets moving out into the distance and the placement cap is very nicely done.

Conclusion:

Lastly, this month we have a new award — the ‘Great Minds Think Alike’ Award, which goes to Stockwell and Prethero for both utilising an ‘ink in water’ theme. So there we go another month bites the dust and yet more great images posted by the AP forum. The next theme is Wildlife and I see that you have already started posting, so I’ll look forward to judging those at the end of the month.

All the best

Garry C-W



Hotblack
(Dead Horse Flogger)
04/06/2007 15:07
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done everyone. Congratulations to Samsam and all the highly commendeds and thanks once more to Garry for judging.

APchris
(Pooh-Bah)
04/06/2007 15:22
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done Samsam, I knew that was a winner as soon as you posted it - and it's not just Gary who's interested in how it was done, please tell!!

Well done to the runners up and thanks again to Gary for judging the comp - very quickly again this month (must have a lot of time on his hands in his new job )


Badgerman
(Nocturnal Non-Scaredy Cat In A Deep Pit)
04/06/2007 15:30
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Great results, well done everyone

datawise
(old hand)
04/06/2007 15:49
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done all, esp. samsam

Mr_Geoff
(tog with no title)
04/06/2007 15:52
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done all!

Seven..
(...or maybe Eight)
04/06/2007 17:27
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

woo hoo a win for Sam shall have to go give him a nudge.

Well done everyone very colourful


El Sid
(Going potty)
04/06/2007 17:40
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done Sam and congratulations to the HCs.

Another tricky round again...


Rustyknight
(old hand)
04/06/2007 17:40
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

P'raps he'll share out the Smarties now between the rest of us!

ian_g
(enthusiast)
04/06/2007 20:17
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Quote:

P'raps he'll share out the Smarties now between the rest of us!




I want an orange one.

First comp entered, first comp won! Good on you, Sam.
Congrats to all the runners-up also


BigWill
(Gorgeous oversensitive Nikon-loving cream puff)
04/06/2007 20:59
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done to the winner and the highly commended and also to the losers.............like me..................I'm off to cut my wrists now!

BigWill


Scphoto
(Little Fruitbat)
04/06/2007 21:32
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Great choice for the winner and a commended for me!

Happy!


Samsam
(newbie)
04/06/2007 22:04
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Wow, I'm made up! Didn't expect that!

Its a straight shot, although I did lighten and darken in a couple of places and cropped down a bit. It was taken with a Panasonic Lumix FZ20. The fun bit was getting the depth of field and the smarties arranged nicely.

Thanks Gary for a great critique - the orange one is yours if I can get it past Ian first and well done to the commendeds

Thanks all

Sam


stockwell
(journeyman)
04/06/2007 23:28
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done Sam, there were some great entries this week, im just chuffed to get a "great minds think alike" award, its made my day & taken my mind off of exams (probably not a good thing) once again congratulations to all the winners & runners up alike

Thanks again
Matthew


bagpuss
(Prolific Pam)
04/06/2007 23:53
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Congratulations!

Ian_A
(Avocadopearaphobe)
05/06/2007 00:18
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Congrats to all, particularly Sam and Graeme - I know where you're coming from ...

Baz94
(addict)
05/06/2007 15:27
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Congrats

AGW
()
05/06/2007 23:18
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Thats a bit like "I know where you've been", but better than "I know what you have been doing"!
Cheers Ian!

Graeme


Mojo_66
(Rain Kat)
05/06/2007 23:26
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Nice one all, would've liked to have seen Mertonia's in there though, it was an interesting take on the theme.

Ian_A
(Avocadopearaphobe)
06/06/2007 07:45
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Quote:

Thats a bit like "I know where you've been", but better than "I know what you have been doing"!






You should have got this month's star prize!


fabs
(Carpal \'Tunnel)
06/06/2007 08:46
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Congrats to all involved!!

mertonia
(old hand)
06/06/2007 16:35
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Yes, well done everyone some great shots. And thanks Mojo 66 for your kind comment

peter


AGW
()
06/06/2007 19:59
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

You are not treating this with the gravity it deserves! I'll have you know that I had to get SRB to make a special Canon atachment for the Hubble so I could catch that one!
Graeme


Hedgehog
(newbie)
06/06/2007 21:43
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

Well done Samsam... that shot did stand out in that collection... but it is the high standard of entries that keeps me coming back here.

Done&rundleCams
(Senior Member)
07/06/2007 08:06
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

well done to you all

cheers,

Jack


AJUK
()
08/06/2007 23:17
Re: Results May 2007 Forum Competition

I'm not doing so well this year


Contact Us | Privacy statement Main website

Generated in 0.011 seconds in which 0.005 seconds were spent on a total of 4 queries. Zlib compression disabled.